podezzyPODezzy

How to choose a niche for print on demand on Etsy

A worked example with Podezzy's Niche Finder and Etsy data (snapshot November 17, 2026): the empty sweep returns terms where a few sellers hold most sales, and four shirt niches are compared on sales, listings, shops and best sellers.

How to choose a niche for print on demand on Etsy

To choose a print-on-demand niche on Etsy, pick a buyer group and the phrase they type, then compare four numbers for it: estimated sales, listings, shops and how much of the sales the biggest three sellers hold. On November 18, 2026 we ran Podezzy's Etsy Niche Finder and checked four shirt niches against Podezzy's Etsy data. The results below show why the number that looks best is often the one to distrust.

What Etsy says about finding demand

Etsy's Seller Handbook article How to Spot Trends and Keywords With Marketplace Insights (November 4, 2025, read November 18, 2026) describes a tool inside Shop Manager that "uses real Etsy search data to show what buyers are looking for in real time, along with how often they're searching and the level of competition for different search terms." Its advice for finding a niche reads: "Compare keywords to see which have high demand but lower listing volume." It also warns that the terms it shows reflect only what buyers search for, so a high-demand term still has to be something you are allowed to list.

Podezzy measures something different. Its numbers are estimated Etsy sales, listings and shops from daily snapshots, not search counts. Etsy's own Marketplace Insights is the place for those. Every figure below is an estimate and carries its date.

What the Niche Finder returns when you press Run

With the box empty, the Niche Finder sweeps more than a million tracked terms and returns up to 25 that score 55 or more on opportunity and 45 or less on competition. We ran it that way on November 18, 2026 and got 25 terms. None of them is a shirt or sweatshirt term. Six are German phrases ("holzschilder trofast" and "namensbuchstabe" among them), and others are terms such as "name address stamp", "employee tote bag" and "elf setup kit". The tool labels all 25 "monopolized_niche".

The reason shows up in the data behind each row. A field named top3_share, which we read as the share of a term's sales held by its three biggest sellers, is 0.80 or higher for 21 of the 25 terms. The other four report 0, which looks like missing data. A low competition score here mostly means that few sellers have the term, and often that a few of them hold most of its sales. "Hot chocolate shot" scores 99.17 on the tool's 7-day opportunity with 15 listings, 6 shops and an estimated 2,931 sales in 30 days, and by that share a few sellers take nearly all of those sales. The tool's own page adds a warning for declining terms: high opportunity there "often just means the sellers have already left".

So a sweep alone does not pick a niche. Use it to spot terms, then check who holds them.

Four shirt niches, same day

Typing one term into the Niche Finder narrows the sweep to that term, and the page shows its row. We chose four niches from the twelve shirt searches that returned data that day, spread across sizes, so they are examples and not a ranking. Sales, listings and shops come from Podezzy's Etsy data for the same snapshot.

NicheEst. sales, 30 daysListingsShopsSales per 100 listingsTop 3 sellers' share
teacher shirt9,899282,20135,9783.56%
dog mom shirt9,826130,87326,3887.522%
pickleball shirt1,19626,5756,7854.510%
pharmacy tech shirt2833,3311,1368.515%

Source: Podezzy Etsy data, snapshot November 17, 2026, pulled November 18, 2026. Estimates. Listings is the Niche Finder's own listings column; Who Ranks For This Keyword tracks a narrower set for each term (3,417 for dog mom shirt). Top 3 sellers' share is the data's top3_share field, which we read as the share of the term's sales held by its three biggest sellers. Sales per 100 listings is our division, and the percentages are our rounding.

None of the four clears the Niche Finder's own bar. Its opportunity scores run from about 4 (teacher shirt) to 15 (dog mom shirt) and its competition scores from about 85 to 95, which are the tool's 7-day scores. That is what a shirt niche with thousands of shops looks like. The table is more useful for how the four differ:

  • Teacher shirt and dog mom shirt sell about the same, 9,899 and 9,826 in 30 days, but teacher has more than twice the listings. On average each dog mom listing has about twice the sales.
  • Pickleball shirt has about a fifth of dog mom's listings and an eighth of its sales, so its demand is smaller and it is not empty: 6,785 shops already sell under it.
  • Pharmacy tech shirt is the smallest, at an estimated 283 sales across 1,136 shops in 30 days.
Hand sketching t-shirt design ideas in colored pencil on loose sheets of paper, with a cup of tea and a small plant

The tool's Sales change column shows -36.6% for teacher shirt and -38.2% for pharmacy tech shirt, while dog mom shirt shows +24.9% and pickleball shirt +7.5%. Listings in the same data rose 22.3%, 30.3%, 29.6% and 30.6%. A listing jump is not special to these four: it was 22% to 42% in the eight other shirt searches that returned data that day. All of this is one 30-day window, and seasonal swings can move it.

Look at who sells under the term

A niche is a search, and the listings that sell under it are what yours competes with. For each term we pulled the 24 listings with the most estimated sales in Who Ranks For This Keyword on Etsy (last 30 days, also November 18, 2026) and read the titles. That list is sorted by sales, not Etsy's search order. To size up one of those sellers on its own, see how to see an Etsy shop's sales and estimate its revenue.

Dog mom shirt stands out. Reading the titles ourselves, 17 of its 24 listings have "custom", "personalized", "photo" or "portrait" in the title, and those 17 hold about 85% of the estimated sales among the 24. The top listing, an embroidered custom dog photo sweatshirt, sells an estimated 542 in 30 days. A ready-made "dog mom" design joins a field where most of the estimated sales go to titles that promise personalization. Teacher shirt, pickleball shirt and pharmacy tech shirt show 5, 6 and 3 such titles out of 24, so personalization plays a smaller part among their best sellers.

Podezzy's Who Ranks For This Keyword on Etsy for dog mom shirt: the five listings with the most estimated sales are custom pet photo, portrait and bootleg shirts

Choosing without a promise

Person seen from behind at a desk looking at a monitor that shows a grid of t-shirt listing thumbnails

Neither a small niche nor a large one is a safe pick. The table gives you the shape of each market, and the choice rests on three questions that numbers only partly answer:

  1. Do the best sellers look like your product? If they are mostly personalized items and you sell ready-made designs, look at a different phrase.
  2. Is the sales total big enough to share? 283 sales a month across 1,136 shops leaves little for a new shop. 9,899 across 35,978 leaves more in absolute terms and more rivals.
  3. Can you keep supplying new designs for this buyer? A niche you cannot feed stalls, whatever the data says.

Take two or three candidates through the same four numbers, drop the ones that fail question one, and list a few designs in the one you can supply best. How a listing sells is what tells you if the niche works, and only time and your own listings answer that. For candidate phrases, the November list of top Etsy keywords shows what is selling, and Etsy Keyword Research gives a term's demand and lifecycle once you have picked one.

POD niche FAQ

What is a good niche for print on demand on Etsy?

One where the design carries the value, such as a hobby, a profession or a pet, and where the best sellers look like products you can make. Among the four we checked, dog mom shirt sells about as much as teacher shirt with less than half the listings, but its best sellers lean on personalized pet items, so the best fit depends on what you can make.

Is a low-competition niche better?

Not by itself. In the Niche Finder's sweep on November 18, 2026, the terms that scored as low competition mostly had a few sellers holding most of the sales: the top three sellers' share was 0.80 or higher in 21 of 25.

How do I check how big a niche is?

Type the term into the Niche Finder and read its 30-day sales and listings, then use Keyword Research for demand and lifecycle. These are estimated Etsy sales activity, not search counts.

Should I pick a broad niche or a narrow one?

The numbers do not choose for you. Pickleball shirt has about an eighth of dog mom shirt's sales and about a fifth of its listings, so narrow means a smaller prize and still thousands of rivals.

What to do next

Write down three phrases a buyer in your niche would type, then run each in the Niche Finder and compare their sales and listings before you design anything. If you plan to name the shop around the niche, Etsy's name rules are in how to change your Etsy shop name.

Every guide here has a tool behind it

Stop guessing. The tools are free and need no account.

Free lookups every day here — or unlimited research, rank tracking and bulk listing across four marketplaces on the full studio.

See the full studio →